Yann Marx/CliC:ME/LISER

Screenshot of the CliC:ME dashboard from the LISER researchers, projecting migration patterns of different population groups worldwide.

How will climate change affect migration globally? How many people will be forced to move? Where will they go? Are people moving across borders or mainly within their own countries? And what does this mean for poverty and inequality, as well as for development aid?

Researchers at the Luxembourg Institute of Socio-Economic Research (LISER) are investigating these questions as part of the CliC:ME research project. To this end, they have created a database that records migration patterns of different population groups worldwide, categorised by age, gender and other social characteristics. Using mathematical models, they are calculating the extent to which climate change will drive people to leave their homes by the end of the century. Based on this, the researchers have created an interactive dashboard that can be used to visualise migration patterns. The project was also presented last year at COP30 in Belém.

We spoke to Michał Burzyński, who heads the research project.

Michał Burzyński is an economist at the Luxembourg Institute of Socio-Economic Research (LISER), where he has worked since 2018. He earned his PhD at the Université catholique de Louvain in Belgium, and Poznan University of Economics in Poland studying how migration, education and economic growth are linked. He also was a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Luxembourg.

His current research looks at how migration shapes economies and societies. He studies who gains and who loses from migration in both origin and destination countries, how migrants fit into labour markets, and how new technologies such as automation interact with migration. He also explores the long-term future of human mobility, including the role of climate change (see an open access online dashboard: clicme.liser.lu).

Photo: LISER 

 

When we talk about climate change and migration, it is easy to imagine that very large numbers of people will flee the regions most severely affected. Your research paints a more nuanced picture. What is actually happening?

Climate change will cause migration – there is little doubt about that. But the picture many people have in mind is often misleading. We do not expect hundreds of millions of people from the poorest regions of the world to move in large numbers to Europe or North America.

Our model does project several hundred million climate-related moves over the course of the 21st century in the pessimistic climate scenario. But most of these movements take place within countries. Only around one fifth are international. And even among these, a large share takes place within the Global South. Migration from the Global South to the Global North accounts for only a comparatively small share of our projections.

This is probably one of the biggest misconceptions in the public debate: when people in the Global North hear very large numbers for climate migration, many imagine hundreds of millions of people arriving at their borders. In reality, most people who move do so much closer to where they already live.

Why do so many people stay in regions where climate change is significantly worsening their living conditions, rather than moving away?

There are very different reasons for this. Some people want to stay because they are strongly attached to their home, family, community, culture or religion. Others would be willing to move but lack the financial resources, information or opportunities to do so. Staying can therefore be voluntary or constrained.

We also see this in surveys we conducted in particularly vulnerable regions of the Caribbean. There, we were able to distinguish between people who wanted to stay and those who would have preferred to move but lacked the necessary resources. These differences vary considerably from one location to another and are strongly shaped by local circumstances and community contexts.

One interesting example concerns whether people are able to move individually or as a group. When only one person  receives support to relocate, willingness to move often remains low because people do not want to leave their family and community behind. However, when an entire community can relocate  together, willingness to move may increase significantly. This highlights the important role that social ties play in migration decisions.

Who can actually afford to use migration as a way of adapting to climate change – and who cannot? What role do income, education and other social inequalities play?

Migration is highly selective. Income matters, but so do age, education, gender, family situation and access to information or visas. There is no simple threshold above which someone migrates. Instead, different factors change the probability that someone will relocate.

We see very clearly, for example, that young men are particularly mobile. Often they do not relocate  only for themselves, but also to send money back to their families. This means that migration is not an adaptation strategy that is equally available to everyone. People with more resources and greater room for manoeuvre are better able to respond to climate risks by changing where they live. In this sense, migration reflects existing social inequalities.

With CliC:ME, you model how climate change and migration could develop towards the end of this century. How does the model work – and how can you determine whether someone is moving because of climate change?

We try to capture many different factors at the same time. The model links economic development, labour markets, trade, demographics and migration with different climate impacts. These include not only impacts of temperature extremes, but also other hazards including sea-level rise, floods, droughts and changes in agricultural yields.

One important feature is the spatial resolution. We divide the world into very small grid cells of around five by five kilometres. For each of these cells, we examine how the economy, population and climate risks change and how these local developments are connected to other regions.

By comparing model simulations with climate hazards to simulations in which climate impacts are switched off, we can identify the direct losses caused by climate change. We can also explicitly determine who moves for climatic reasons, where these people go, and what the economic consequences of these movements are.

Screenshot from clicme.liser.lu. This shows net migration (change in population figures due to immigration and emigration for Central Africa under the RCP 7.0 climate scenario, projected up to 2090. RCP 7.0 is a climate scenario in which greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise sharply. It describes a possible future characterised by significant climate change. Find out more at clicme.liser.lu. (Credit: Yann Marx, LISER)

When climate migration is discussed, very different figures are cited – from several hundred million to more than a billion. How can such figures be compared at all?

You have to look very carefully at what is actually being counted. Models differ in whether they look at short-term displacement or permanent migration, whether they capture internal or international movements, and over what period they calculate them.

CliC:ME looks at long-term migration over periods of 20 years. Short-term displacement following floods, hurricanes or other disasters is not included. Many people who temporarily leave their homes after such events return after a short period. That is fundamentally different from a permanent move.

This is why figures from different studies cannot simply be placed side by side. The numbers can look very different even when the studies do not necessarily contradict each other. The key questions are always: What kind of migration is being measured, over what period, and at what spatial scale?

CliC:ME shows not only migration, but also that many people remain despite increasing climate-related damage. What are the consequences of this immobility for poverty and inequality?

From a humanitarian perspective, this is probably the greater challenge. Many people remain in regions where they are increasingly exposed to the consequences of climate change even as their livelihoods, incomes and employment opportunities decline.

If people cannot move away, they bear a larger share of the damage themselves. This increases the risk of falling into poverty. In our model, climate impacts could push more than  200 million additional adults below the extreme poverty line by the end of the century. For comparison, around 400 million people worldwide currently live in extreme poverty. This illustrates the scale of the problem.

So we are not only talking about climate migration, but also about climate immobility. The crucial question then becomes: How can we support people where they want to stay – or where they have no choice but to stay?

In your recent policy brief, you also examine what policy and development aid can do. Where should support be targeted if migration is not a realistic adaptation strategy for many of the most vulnerable people?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer. What works depends strongly on the local context. Models can show where problems are emerging and which measures might in principle make sense. But to know what actually works in a particular region or community, we need additional local evidence.

That is why we combine theoretical modelling with field studies and experiments. This allows us to assess more effectively whether people need support to relocate or whether adaptation in place is the more appropriate strategy. The key is to tailor measures to the actual needs and opportunities of the people concerned.

Which implication of your research should receive more attention in international climate policy?

Climate migration is real and it presents significant  challenges. But we should pay just as much attention to the people who cannot or do not want to migrate. We should also remember that the differences between climate scenarios are enormous. The less warming there is, the lower the levels of climate-related poverty and migration are likely to be. For me, the most important message is therefore this: every tenth of a degree of warming that we avoid matters.

Interview: Hannes Schlender (scienceRELATIONS)
Editor: Michèle Weber (FNR) 

Infobox

References

Burzyński, M., Docquier, F., & Szymańska, A. (2024). Climate Change: Migration Economics, CliC:ME, LISER. Version 0.1. [Online] Available at: http://clicme.liser.lu/

Michał Burzyński, Christoph Deuster, Frédéric Docquier, Jaime de Melo, Climate Change, Inequality, and Human Migration, Journal of the European Economic Association, Volume 20, Issue 3, June 2022, Pages 1145–1197, https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvab054

Climate adaptation in Luxembourg’s development aid: why most people will stay and need support where they live | LISER

Aussi intéréssant

Ziel mir keng! – De Science Check Ziel mir keng: qu’est-ce que cela signifie d’être pauvre ?

Qu’est-ce que la pauvreté au juste ? Comment peut-on la mesurer ? Et quelles sont les conséquences pour les gens qui viv...

FNR
Projet Horizon 2020 La pauvreté au travail : Une équipe internationale recherche des raisons et des solutions

Le projet de recherche paneuropéen « Working, Yet Poor » s’est récemment vu attribuer 3,2 millions d’euros pour trois an...

La recherche s’invite dans les vignobles Comment la viticulture luxembourgeoise s'adapte au changement climatique

Les temps où le changement climatique n’exerçait que des effets positifs sur la viticulture sont révolus. Les scientifiq...

LIST , IVV

Aussi dans cette rubrique

Spotlight on Young Researchers Garantir une utilisation durable de l'eau au Luxembourg

Le secteur agricole au Luxembourg consomme près d'un dixième de l'eau potable disponible – et la demande est en hausse. Des chercheurs étudient comment réutiliser l'eau de manière intelligente.

industry metallurgical plant dawn smoke smog emissions bad ecology aerial photography
Capturing CO2 Are we ready for carbon capture (in Luxembourg)?

Luxembourg hits Overshoot Day again early. As CO₂ emissions keep rising, which is contributing to the problem, we ask: could Carbon Capture, Utilisation and Storage (CCUS) be part of the solution?

Urbanisme et santé Comment les villes peuvent-elles être conçues de manière à réduire le stress ?

La vie en ville est attrayante, mais elle peut aussi être stressante. L'étude FragMent veut aider à concevoir des villes qui favorisent le bien-être.

Insectes pollinisateurs « Les abeilles sauvages sont indispensables pour la biodiversité »

Depuis six ans, le 'naturmusée' se consacre à l'étude des abeilles sauvages au Luxembourg. Les préparatifs pour l'atlas des abeilles sauvages battent leur plein. Nous avons eu un avant-goût.